Sad beyond words. That is the only proper way to describe the lament in my heart and the knowledge that this year is the first Christmas we will be celebrating without Merry, my daughter’s Elf on the Shelf.
For so much of her young life, Ava cherished her elf, Merry. She would carefully write notes to her before bed each night leading up to Christmas. She would often be unable to sleep, so excited was she for the antics she’d surely find in the morning.
My wife would concoct the most amazing and intricate displays of its impish behavior, always accompanied by a note on an index card penned in Merry’s name. Ava used to love her elf so much she would even wish it to come visit her on her birthday. That was often her one and only wish for a birthday present: a chance to see her magic Christmas elf even if for a single day (many months after Christmas)!
Those days are now lost and beyond me… like somber sands in the hourglass that can never again rise to fall anew.
I lament the clock which cannot wind back the years; I lament the innocence of youth so brazenly tarnished by maturity; I lament the hours that are lost and gone forever; I lament the quiet charm of a beautiful lie that gave so much joy but existed only for a brief moment and then was extinguished.
Taken with these melancholy thoughts tonight, I penned the following poem. It suggests a far distant and future year, one in which the elf magic will arise anew in her own children. The beautiful lie shall become Sacred once again…
===
The Beautiful Christmas Lie
In the hush of deep December (when the stars like scattered ember)
Lit the velvet vault of heaven with a thousand lamps of gold,
Lived a little girl named Ava, whom the winter seemed to favor,
Whose imagination wandered where those silver moonbeams rolled…
Where the pinewoods slept in splendor, and where secret winds blew cold.
When the world was young and golden, and its wonders yet untold!
Oh, the shimmering, the glimmering, the candlelight a-shimmering
On the garlands, on the stairways, on our frosted window glass!
How the snowflakes, softly streaming, set the sleepy mountains dreaming!
How the shadows danced like fairies where the winter breezes passed;
Every evening brought enchantment, every morning came too fast.
And the joy of Christmas lingered like a spell too sweet to last.
There were ribbons bright and gleaming, there were silver angels dreaming,
There were bells that rang like laughter through the fragrant, frosted air;
There were stockings, softly swaying, little voices, laughing, playing…
And among the many marvels was a doll with scarlet hair:
A little elf of Christmas (with a smile past compare)
Who appeared in the bright morning, come from Santa’s silver lair.
Oh, how she loved that little creature! Every bright and painted feature.
Every mischievous expression, every tiny pointed shoe!
She would search at early morning, while the winter light was dawning…
For the secret little traveler and the mischief it would do;
On the mantel, by the mirror, in the branches wet with dew.
Every day a fresh enchantment, every day a world made new.
Sometimes high among the branches, where firelight softly dances.
Sometimes perched beside the window, gazing outward at the snow;
Sometimes dangling from the ceiling, with a face of merry feeling.
Sometimes hidden in the kitchen where the nightlight shadows glow.
And my dear child, laughter ringing, never questioned how or why,
For she KNEW that Christmas magic made her little creature fly.
Oh, the tender art of dreaming! Oh, the bright and blissful seeming
Of a world where every object held a secret of its own!
Where the night was thick with wonder, where the stars would softly thunder
In the endless blue of heaven where raging winds had blown;
And that smallest painted figure, sitting silent and alone
Held a universe of marvels that the waking world not known.
But the seasons, ever turning, brought the strange, insistent yearning
Of a mind that sought to fathom what the trusting heart adored…
And with each successive winter, came a little silver splinter
Of a question, cruel dark question, that no wonder could afford.
For the child, still enchanted, felt a doubt she had ignored,
And the magic, once unquestioned, met a mind that now explored…
Was it strange (she thought one morning) as the eastern sky was dawning
That the elf did never move while she watched it from her chair?
That its smile sat always painted, that its little face was quaintly
Set in one eternal visage, never changing, never rare?
And the thought, though faintly troubling, grew more frequent in her prayers…
Like a breeze through winter branches, like a dark whisper in the air.
Alas, a new and frightful year came stealing, with its softly shifting feeling
And my child began to notice how the wonders came to be…
How her elf would change her station, how some odd and small occasion
Seemed to happen when her mother rose before the family.
And the mind, once lost in dreaming, now was restless to be free
To discover what was hidden in the things she could not see.
Oh, the sorrow of discerning! Oh, the bittersweet unlearning
When the heart begins to tremble at the knowledge it pursues!
For the questions came like raindrops, and the bright and lovely dream stopped
Being something she could cherish without wondering if it were true!
And the wonder, once a garden, slowly altered in her view…
Till the flower of believing seemed to fade beneath the dew.
Then one night, in bleak December, came the moment she’d remember
Long beyond the years of yearning, long beyond the somber tree;
For she woke to faintly stirring footsteps, soft as winter’s whisper,
And she followed, through the darkness, where the secret seemed to be.
There she saw her mother standing, placing gently, carefully,
That same small Christmas elf upon the shelf where it would come to stately be.
How the silence seemed to shatter! Oh, how the world began to scatter!
How the stars beyond the window lost their ancient, tender glow!
For the elf was but a figure, and her wondrous small creature
Had been moved by human fingers through the nights of falling snow.
All the journeys, all the stories, all the secret things she’d known
Were inventions of her mother, and the magic was her own!
And lo! Oh, how she stood there scarcely breathing with the sorrow of believing
In a shell that had no being, in a truth that had no name;
For the world she once had so cherished: all its mystery had perished!
And the little elf sat smiling, smiling, smiling, though the world was not the same.
How the painted face seemed mocking! How our fire’s golden flame
Burned as brightly as before her… though it seemed to burn with shame.
If the elf had been invented, what of all the things presented
As the Sacred, as the splendid, as the wonders she had known?
What of Santa’s midnight flying? What of wishes, whispered, sighing?
What of angels, what of heaven, what of kindness yet unshown?
If a thing could seem so certain, yet be nothing but a dream…
Could the whole of human meaning be so hollow as it seemed?
Then I fear the years grew cold and clever, and the child began to sever
Every story from its meaning, every intrigue from its art;
For the mind, with no precision, made its deep and blunt incision,
And the world, once clothed in wonder, stood exposed before her heart!
She could see the hands behind it, could discern each hidden part;
Yet the knowledge left her lonely… like a small lantern in the dark.
Oh, the villainous, sad delight of taking everything apart!
Of explaining all the marvels, of declaring what they are!
How the spirit, in its striving, thinks that knowing means arriving…
And mistakes the cold dismantling for the beauty of the star.
For lo, the Sun, once bright with wonder, becomes now a distant fire!
And the heart, a-flow with knowledge, has lost a portion of desire.
Still the snow fell soft and shivered, still the moon upon the river
Cast its thousand trembling flakes upon the sleeping winter land;
Still the trees were crowned with crystal, still the church bells sounded wistful.
Still the world was full of beauty she could no longer understand.
For the beauty had not vanished, though the meaning seemed to cease,
And the world, though still enchanted, gave such little sense of peace.
Years went by, and Ava wandered through the wide and waking world…
Through the seasons, through the sorrows, through the strange and shifting years.
She had learned to question freely, learned to reason deeply, dearly!
Learned that truths could live in silence, learned that love could live with tears.
And my gentle, pristine daughter with eyes once innocent with light
Grew into a woman wiser, as sadly is their plight.
For just as Adam, sweetly dreaming, saw the fruit of Eden gleaming,
And with Eve, in fateful longing, tasted what the vile serpent bore,
Came the Knowing, came the Seeing, came the dreadful cost of being
Wise enough to see the heavens! (yet not wise to dwell too near its shores);
For their eyes were opened wider, but the Garden closed its door
And they gained a world of wisdom, yet lost dear Eden evermore.
Yet hark! For one distant winter, faintly gleaming, while the snowy fields lay dreaming,
Comes a child to her keeping, comes a laughter warm and new;
And the house, so long grown quiet, fills with merry little riot,
Fills with whispers! fills with wishes! fills with everything she knew!
For her daughter loves December, loves the candles and the snow…
Loves the secret sense of wonder that the young alone may know.
And one evening, softly falling, while the winter winds comes calling,
Ava finds among her treasures that old elf of crimson dress;
Still the little face is smiling, still the painted eyes beguiling,
Still the tiny figure casts all its old and sweet excess.
And she holds it in her fingers, and a warm memory returns,
Of the childhood she had cherished, and a lesson she once learned.
How she once saw her mother bending, how she saw soft hands extending…
And realizes the quiet labor of those long-forgotten nights.
Every morning’s bright surprise, every joy in her bright eyes
Had been fashioned by a mother out of tenderness and light!
And the thing she thought deception, in the years of her despair
Was the love that moved in secret by a heart that cared.
Oh, the sudden, sweet revealing! Oh, the deep and tender feeling:
Bearing witness to the meaning of a wondrous, sacred lie.
For the elf had never wandered, yet the child truly wondered!
And the joy had been as living as the tears within her eyes.
Though the figure was a fiction, though the story was untrue…
What it still gave the wee dreamer was a goodness pure and true.
Was her laughter less for knowing? Was the sweetness less for showing
That the bright mystery was woven by the hands that loved her best?
Was the Christmas morning hollow? Did the warmth no longer follow
From the simple act of giving, from the kindness manifest?
If the love had been the substance, if the story was the dress
Then the Truth was not diminished by the falsehood it possessed!
And the thought grew bright and brighter, till her heart became soon lighter,
Till the years of cold negation seemed to soften and unwind;
For there are truths beyond construction, such as moving through destruction;
These are ones the dismal hand of reason cannot wholly hope to find.
There are fictions that awaken what the facts may leave asleep,
There are stories that can carry truths too tragic and too deep.
For the Sacred is not banished when the lovely dream has vanished.
Nor is meaning only worthy when the mind has proved it so;
There are things we make in kindness, there are gifts that overcome us…
There are seeds that bloom in winter where we never thought they’d grow.
And the heart that once dismantled all the magic it had known
May discover, in the ruins, something lovelier has grown.
Placing the lie now on its shelf and smiling a secret to herself
The room becomes a kingdom as it had so long before;
Not because the doll was living, but because the act of giving
Made a wonder worth preserving, made a meaning worth much more.
For her child would wake in laughter, and the mother, knowing well,
Would become the unseen magic of the story she could tell.
So the next morning comes with singing, and the little feet come springing.
And her daughter finds the elf there, perched upon the living tree;
And her eyes grow wide with wonder, and her heart grows bright as thunder;
And she laughs with all the gladness that a little child can be.
And her mother, watching softly, feels the years dissolve away…
For the magic had returned there, in a new and darling way.
Oh, the strange and splendid turning! Oh, the wisdom born of learning
That the road beyond believing need not end in disbelief!
For the mind may strip the story, may expose its borrowed glory,
Yet the heart may find, beneath it, something richer than its grief!
(Not the innocence of childhood, not the blind and simple trust)
But a wonder chosen freely, rising boldly from the dust!
And when bitter years and frothy fears have stolen magic from her daughter,
When the little elf lies silent and the bright illusion fades,
She will know the same cold sorrow, taste the savage truth tomorrow,
And behold the painted, lifeless doll that some corporation made.
Yet beyond the many years of doubting, when her own small child’s free,
She might then take that elf and place it where her wide-eyed child sees.
Thus the wonder passes onward, ever outward, ever homeward
Through the hands that make the magic, through the hearts that learn its art;
And the falsehood, though invented, finds its purpose reinvented
As a vessel made of kindness, as a dim language of the heart.
For the child trusts the story, and the mother knows its worth…
And between them lives a beauty that no logic can unearth.
For each, the snow falls soft and slowly, and their home grows safer, holy.
And the stars above the chimney seem to nearly tremble in the night…
While the elf, so still and smiling, sits upon the shelf, beguiling:
Just one more tool in a kingdom made of tenderness and light.
And the mother bites the apple, yet is still richer than before;
For she knows the spell is broken, yet conjures it once more.





